I often write about the "can do nothing wrong"
iPhone and "it's not an iPhone"
Android. Clearly, I've been biased for a while and I can recognize that. It's the same ongoing debate that has plagued tech-enthusiasts for as long as there has been competition. Betamax vs. VHS, Mac OS X vs. Windows, DVD vs. DivX (Ha!), HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray, and of course iOS vs. Android. So, enough is enough, and even though my previous post about the
Galaxy Nexus led me to believe I had made up my mind, I have to admit- the interest was still there.
Now, I don't update frequently enough, don't have enough
Klout, nor do I have enough readers to make a case to just ask Samsung for a demo unit for review purposes, so as the title of the post suggests I needed to put some money into this debate. As a quick recap, Android 4.0 finally sparked my interest to a boiling point that I had to truly use it and not just demo it at a store. Also, I needed to see if
Verizon Wireless would be the savior so many make it out to be. I've been in San Francisco this week so having a true need to rely on mobile devices and data, I decided what better time than now to have my own little experiment.
To put things into context: I am still in contract with
AT&T with my iPhone 4 that I received the day before it was officially released in 2010. It still works great. I still
love it. I bought a Samsung Galaxy Nexus on Verizon and am going to make the best of the 2-week trial period. The bottom line is if Android wins me over, I will port my number over from AT&T and cancel that contract. Oh and of course, I will have switched to Android in one fell swoop defying all that I've known for the past 4 years in terms of iOS world. However, if it doesn't, well then I'm left with two additional options: return the Nexus, pay fees and what not, and get a Verizon iPhone 4S instead (with only 2GB of data for $30/mo. instead of the current promotion of double-data for 4G devices) or cancel Verizon altogether and stick with my unlimited AT&T data plan and the trusty ol' iPhone 4. Unfortunately, working in New York City, AT&T is the bane of my existence but anyway...
My impression so far has been mixed. At certain times, I see something as minute as the font on ICS and it makes all the difference whereas other times I want to throw the phone away. The Nexus screen is huge and beautiful.
ICS's multi-tasking feature is excellent, the notification bar and swipe down has always been a strong point and is still very good. Oh, and lest not forget- Verizon's 4G LTE network is blazing fast. I couldn't believe how fast I was downloading apps and refreshing my social networks. The horsepower underneath the huge screen is quick, snappy, and fluid as well. I would never have classified anything Android-based to be fluid before 4.0. The app market is strong, the built-in Google apps have all been updated and they're excellent.
However, 4 years of iOS sophistication and polish causes extra scrutiny to other features:
- The GPS functionality is awful. I can never locate anything on FourSquare without searching for it. The Google Maps app, while outstanding UI (especially the pinch/zoom 3D building models), is inaccurate.
- The camera is garbage. Sure, it has a very fast shutter speed when set to "Action" but the colors are washed out, all the photos look blurry, and the interface is still unintuitive. Perhaps this is the biggest deciding factor for me. I love the iPhone 4 camera, and the 4S is supposed to be much better than that? You're kidding, right? That doesn't leave any competition for Google.
Samsung Galaxy Nexus (5MP Auto, Flash Off)
Apple iPhone 4 (5MP, Not HDR, Flash Off)
- The battery. Should I even elaborate? Well, I need to because due to my need for maximizing battery life for all of my portable devices, I purposely have my brightness turned down to the lowest setting, bluetooth disabled, WiFi disabled, GPS disabled (except when I need to use a location-based app), and the usual big vampire- 4G disabled. I let the phone stay on 3G and with every service basically turned off. Getting a full work-day worth of battery out of the device was a struggle. I think it finally gave out around 11 hours after a full-charge and minimal usage. 4G or not, this is unacceptable. In fact, with having it on 3G, and everything practically turned off/down, I couldn't even get 12 hours? Really Samsung/Google? You guys couldn't even figure that out? Steve Jobs has laid out what you guys needed to do for over 2 years now.
- The build quality isn't as toyish as I hinted at in my previous post, but it is still made out of plastic, and does feel cheap when comparing to an iPhone (but this wouldn't cause me to not keep it).
I've been very adamant about giving this phone an honest chance, but if I have to treat it with such care for a whole day's worth of usage (or lack thereof) then it just isn't feasible. Sure, I could follow Android users advice- always keep a charger with you wherever you go and pack 19 extra batteries with me, but that's just silly.
Contrary to the tone of the aforementioned shortcomings, I could still see myself making the jump. If I were to ever cross over, it'd be for this device and now. However, there is a huge factor that I never even thought of when having all this debate in my head (and heart) about all this. I can't seem to love the Nexus.
When I first bought the iPhone 3G in 2008, the first week I thought I had made a grave mistake. "A touch-screen? I can't type on this! What the heck was I thinking? Apps? I don't need apps! It doesn't even support MMS!" But by the third day, I started really appreciating all the little details you notice only when truly using the device and I found myself falling in love with it. I know it sounds corny, but it's true. There have only been a handful of electronic devies that I have gained more appreciation for after the 'honeymoon phase' would wear off. Oh, and my iPhone 3G from 2008 still works just fine. In fact, my mother uses it as her primary phone. The iPhone 4? This was love at first sight. The specs, the features, the look, the feel, everything. I truly love everything about the iPhone 4 in terms of hardware. iOS 5 just sealed the deal and put the icing on the cake (insert additional clichés here). I'm sure I'd love the iPhone 4S just as much (if not more), but I'm not eligible for the upgrade yet (woo-hoo AT&T!).
After about 3 days of trying to utilize the Nexus as my primary smartphone, I found myself digging and reaching for my iPhone more and more. I yearned for it. It felt right. It felt comfortable. If I had to make a decision right now, I'd go back but I am forcing myself to continue to explore Android 4.0 and its nuances so I can find the little gems that Google may have hidden. ICS has its own fair share of little details that I wouldn't have discovered unless I had performed this little, albeit expensive experiment, so we'll see. I've found a few workarounds for some of my gripes, but the battery issue is still a major concern. Seven more days until I make a decision.
[overly enthusiastic] Stay Tuned for the 2nd part of the experiment/experience next weekend!